http://www.doctrine-project.org/jira This file is an XML representation of an issue en-us 5.2.7 850 21-02-2013 http://www.doctrine-project.org/jira/browse/DC-67 Doctrine 1 <p>After enabling Taggable extension, magic methods on the tables (e.g. getPopularTags)<br/> cannot be reached:</p> <p>Doctrine::getTable('Upload')-&gt;getPopularTags();</p> <p>Fatal error: Uncaught exception 'Doctrine_Table_Exception' with message 'Unknown method Doctrine_Table::getPopularTags' in C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\lib\Doctrine\Table.php:2608 Stack trace: #0 <span class="error">&#91;internal function&#93;</span>: Doctrine_Table-&gt;__call('getPopularTags', Array) #1 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\index.php(7): Doctrine_Table-&gt;getPopularTags() #2 </p> {main} <p> thrown in C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\lib\Doctrine\Table.php on line 2608</p> PHP 5.2.8, Doctrine 1.2.0 Alpha1, Vista, Sandbox 1.2.0 Alpha1 DC-67

Taggable not working

Bug Major Reopened Unresolved Jonathan H. Wage admirau Mon, 28 Sep 2009 10:49:57 +0000 Thu, 15 Apr 2010 14:50:14 +0000 1.2.0-ALPHA1 Extensions 4 4 <p>The same with Alpha2</p> <p>Running the tests results in one failure:</p> <p>Doctrine Unit Tests<br/> ===================<br/> Doctrine_Template_Taggable_TestCase.............................................failed</p> <p>Unexpected Doctrine_Connection_Sqlite_Exception thrown in <span class="error">&#91;Doctrine_Template_Taggable_TestCase&#93;</span> with message [SQLSTATE<span class="error">&#91;HY000&#93;</span>: General error: 1 no such column: a__2] in C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\lib\Doctrine\Connection.php on line 1067</p> <p>Trace<br/> -------------</p> <p>#0 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\lib\Doctrine\Connection.php(1015): Doctrine_Connection-&gt;rethrowException(Object(PDOException), Object(Doctrine_Connection_Sqlite))<br/> #1 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\lib\Doctrine\Query\Abstract.php(936): Doctrine_Connection-&gt;execute('SELECT t.id AS ...', Array)<br/> #2 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\lib\Doctrine\Query\Abstract.php(990): Doctrine_Query_Abstract-&gt;_execute(Array)<br/> #3 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tools\sandbox\extensions\Taggable\lib\Doctrine\Template\TaggableTag.php(76): Doctrine_Query_Abstract-&gt;execute(Array, 2)<br/> #4 <span class="error">&#91;internal function&#93;</span>: Doctrine_Template_TaggableTag-&gt;getPopularTagsTableProxy(Array)<br/> #5 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\lib\Doctrine\Record.php(2569): call_user_func_array(Array, Array)<br/> #6 <span class="error">&#91;internal function&#93;</span>: Doctrine_Record-&gt;__call('getPopularTagsT...', Array)<br/> #7 <span class="error">&#91;internal function&#93;</span>: TaggableTag-&gt;getPopularTagsTableProxy(Array)<br/> #8 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\lib\Doctrine\Table.php(2605): call_user_func_array(Array, Array)<br/> #9 <span class="error">&#91;internal function&#93;</span>: Doctrine_Table-&gt;__call('getPopularTags', Array)<br/> #10 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tools\sandbox\extensions\Taggable\tests\Template\TaggableTestCase.php(216): Doctrine_Table-&gt;getPopularTags(Array)<br/> #11 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tests\DoctrineTest\UnitTestCase.php(144): Doctrine_Template_Taggable_TestCase-&gt;testGetPopularTags()<br/> #12 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tests\DoctrineTest\GroupTest.php(61): UnitTestCase-&gt;run()<br/> #13 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tests\DoctrineTest.php(180): GroupTest-&gt;run(Object(DoctrineTest_Reporter_Cli), '')<br/> #14 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tools\sandbox\extensions\Taggable\tests\run.php(29): DoctrineTest-&gt;run()<br/> #15 </p> {main} <p>Tested: 1 test cases.<br/> Successes: 26 passes.<br/> Failures: 1 fails.<br/> Number of new Failures: 0 <br/> Number of fixed Failures: 0 </p> <p>Tests ran in 1 seconds and used 15279.15625 KB of memory</p> <p>The tests all pass now.</p> <p><a href="http://www.doctrine-project.org/extension/Taggable/1_2-1_0/tests" class="external-link">http://www.doctrine-project.org/extension/Taggable/1_2-1_0/tests</a></p> <p>It still does not work on my environment (Windows or Ubuntu 9.10, PHP 5.3/5.2.6)<br/> The test result is a bit different, but still fails:</p> <p>Doctrine Unit Tests<br/> ===================<br/> Doctrine_Template_Taggable_TestCase.............................................failed</p> <p>Unexpected Doctrine_Record_UnknownPropertyException thrown in <span class="error">&#91;Doctrine_Template_Taggable_TestCase&#93;</span> with message <span class="error">&#91;Unknown record property / related component &quot;total_num&quot; on &quot;TaggableTag&quot;&#93;</span> in /home/user/doctrine12b/lib/Doctrine/Record/Filter/Standard.php on line 55</p> <p>Trace<br/> -------------</p> <p>#0 /home/taat/doctrine12b/lib/Doctrine/Record.php(1359): Doctrine_Record_Filter_Standard-&gt;filterGet(Object(TaggableTag), 'total_num')<br/> #1 /home/taat/doctrine12b/lib/Doctrine/Record.php(1318): Doctrine_Record-&gt;_get('total_num', true)<br/> #2 /home/taat/doctrine12b/lib/Doctrine/Access.php(117): Doctrine_Record-&gt;get('total_num')<br/> #3 /home/taat/doctrine12b/tools/sandbox/extensions/Taggable/tests/Template/TaggableTestCase.php(217): Doctrine_Access-&gt;offsetGet('total_num')<br/> #4 /home/taat/doctrine12b/tests/DoctrineTest/UnitTestCase.php(144): Doctrine_Template_Taggable_TestCase-&gt;testGetPopularTags()<br/> #5 /home/taat/doctrine12b/tests/DoctrineTest/GroupTest.php(61): UnitTestCase-&gt;run()<br/> #6 /home/taat/doctrine12b/tests/DoctrineTest.php(180): GroupTest-&gt;run(Object(DoctrineTest_Reporter_Cli), '')<br/> #7 /home/taat/doctrine12b/tools/sandbox/extensions/Taggable/tests/run.php(29): DoctrineTest-&gt;run()<br/> #8 </p> {main} <p>Tested: 1 test cases.<br/> Successes: 26 passes.<br/> Failures: 1 fails.<br/> Number of new Failures: 0 <br/> Number of fixed Failures: 0 </p> <p>Did you update Doctrine? I fixed something in Doctrine 1.2 that fixes it.</p> <p>Yes, the results above ("total_num") I get after updating to 1.2.0-BETA1.<br/> At 1.2.0-ALPHA2 it was "no such column: a__2" (see above comments).</p> <p>Do the extensions work with 2.0, or they are 1.2 specific?</p> <p>1.2 specific. I don't get any fails now, can you try and troubleshoot it and figure out why it fails for you? They don't fail for me anywhere.</p> <p>Doctrine_Template_Taggable_TestCase::testGetPopularTags()<br/> line 214:<br/> $test = Doctrine::getTable('TaggableTag')-&gt;getPopularTags(array('ArticleTaggableTest', 'ArticleTaggableTest2'));</p> <p>// compare this with your results<br/> echo serialize($test);<br/> result:<br/> C:19:"Doctrine_Collection":169:{a:7:{s:4:"data";a:0:{}s:6:"_table";s:11:"TaggableTag";s:9:"_snapshot";a:0:{}s:14:"referenceField";N;s:9:"keyColumn";s:4:"name";s:8:"_locator";N;s:10:"_resources";a:0:{}}}</p> <p>When I try to var_dump($test),<br/> I get circular dependency.<br/> I tried to save results of var_dump($test) to disk, by I get 1,5GB file, and still growing...</p> <p>Maybe this article helps somehow:<br/> <a href="http://www.bigroom.co.uk/blog/php-nesting-level-too-deep-recursive-dependency" class="external-link">http://www.bigroom.co.uk/blog/php-nesting-level-too-deep-recursive-dependency</a></p> <p>Can I see the fix you mentioned above?</p> <p>I'm sorry, but I do not know what else I can do.<br/> Any ideas?</p> <p>I am not sure what to say since it is working for me on all the machines I test. I'll be happy to look if I can get something to fail so I can troubleshoot it.</p> <p>I've tested on PLD Linux too.<br/> The same thing.</p> <p>Could you provide sample server/php configuration on which the tests are passing?</p> <p>Can you describe the fix you've made to correct the errors with ''Unknown method Doctrine_Table::getPopularTags'.<br/> Maybe I can manage to investigate it, but I do not know where to start.</p> <p>Sorry for reopening this again.</p> <p>After upgrading to BETA2 all Taggable tests are passing OK for me too.</p> <p>However, in the code I still get 'Unknown method BlogPostTable::getPopularTags' in /tools\sandbox\lib\Doctrine\Table.php:2793'<br/> Isn't it a regression of the bug you've already fixed before ALPHA2?</p> <p>Here is the description of how I came to this exception.</p> <p>At the very end of config.php:</p> <p>$manager-&gt;registerExtension('Taggable');</p> <p>In the index.php:</p> <p>&lt;?php</p> <p>require_once('config.php');</p> <p>$models = Doctrine_Core::loadModels('models');</p> <p>$post = new BlogPost();<br/> $post-&gt;title = 'This is a sample blog post';<br/> $post-&gt;description = 'Cool!';<br/> $post-&gt;setTags('2009, symfony, doctrine');<br/> $post-&gt;save();</p> <p>$table = Doctrine::getTable('BlogPost');<br/> echo get_class($table); // echoes Doctrine_Collection<br/> $table-&gt;getPopularTags(); // this throws the exception</p> <p>Then in the console:<br/> php doctrine.php create-db<br/> php doctrine.php generate-models-yaml (BaseBlogPost, BlogPost, BlogPostTable were generated)<br/> php doctrine.php generate-sql (see SQL below)<br/> php doctrine.php create-tables<br/> (all ok)</p> <p>php index.php</p> <p>result:</p> <p>BlogPostTablePHP Fatal error: Uncaught exception 'Doctrine_Table_Exception' with message 'Unknown method BlogPostTable::getPopularTags' in C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tools\sandbox\lib\Doctrine\Table.php:2793<br/> Stack trace:<br/> #0 <span class="error">&#91;internal function&#93;</span>: Doctrine_Table-&gt;__call('getPopularTags', Array)<br/> #1 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tools\sandbox\index.php(15): BlogPostTable-&gt;getPopularTags()<br/> #2 </p> {main}<br/> thrown in C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tools\sandbox\lib\Doctrine\Table.php on line 2793<br/> Fatal error: Uncaught exception 'Doctrine_Table_Exception' with message 'Unknown method BlogPostTable::getPopularTags' in C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tools\sandbox\lib\Doctrine\Table.php:2793<br/> Stack trace:<br/> #0 <span class="error">&#91;internal function&#93;</span>: Doctrine_Table-&gt;__call('getPopularTags', Array)<br/> #1 C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tools\sandbox\index.php(15): BlogPostTable-&gt;getPopularTags()<br/> #2 {main} <p> thrown in C:\Users\user\www\extens.dev\tools\sandbox\lib\Doctrine\Table.php on line 2793</p> <p>And here is the generated SQL:</p> <p>CREATE TABLE taggable_tag (id INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT, name VARCHAR(255) UNIQUE);<br/> CREATE TABLE blog_post_taggable_tag (id INTEGER, tag_id INTEGER, PRIMARY KEY(id, tag_id));<br/> CREATE TABLE blog_post (id INTEGER PRIMARY KEY AUTOINCREMENT, title VARCHAR(255) NOT NULL, description VARCHAR(255) NOT NULL);</p> <p>When I test your code, it is working for me. You sure you don't have some old versions of PHP or something?</p> <p>Everything is up to date.<br/> Tested on different servers, with different operating systems, different versions PHP, different versions of Doctrine, by different people.</p> <p>Common thing for all these machines is that PHP (&gt;5.2.10 &lt;= 5.3.1) was installed from precompiled builds, not from source.</p> <p>The error I get now is the same error I got earlier (at the beginning of this topic), which disapperared after your fix.<br/> Then appeared the second error, which was fixed in BETA2, but the previous error is back. (strange, but the tests are passing now, despite the errors in the regular code).</p> <p>When I find some spare time I'll try to trace the changes you've made since the beginning of the topic.</p> <p>Maybe the models are generated not properly.<br/> Here are my models (three) for the reproduction procedure (above):</p> <p>class BlogPostTable extends Doctrine_Table {}</p> <p>class BlogPost extends BaseBlogPost {}</p> <p>abstract class BaseBlogPost extends Doctrine_Record<br/> {<br/> public function setTableDefinition()</p> { $this-&gt;setTableName('blog_post'); $this-&gt;hasColumn('title', 'string', 255, array( 'type' =&gt; 'string', 'notnull' =&gt; true, 'length' =&gt; '255', )); $this-&gt;hasColumn('description', 'string', 255, array( 'type' =&gt; 'string', 'notnull' =&gt; true, 'length' =&gt; '255', )); } <p> public function setUp()</p> { parent::setUp(); $taggable0 = new Doctrine_Template_Taggable(); $this-&gt;actAs($taggable0); } <p>}</p> <p>I have everything generated the same as you.</p> <p>Also getting this. Using doctrine 1.2.0-beta3 and also tried with latest SVN. Taggable is latest available.</p> <p>PHP 5.3.0 running on Zend Server version 5.0.0Beta2</p> <p>No changes after upgrade to 1.2.0-RC1.</p> <p>Maybe this helps somehow:</p> <p>// Following line throws:<br/> // Doctrine_Table_Exception: Unknown method Doctrine_Table::getPopularTags in /home/user/doctrine12rc1/lib/Doctrine/Table.php on line 2799<br/> $tags = Doctrine::getTable('BlogPost')-&gt;getPopularTags();</p> <p>// This line returns collection of tags, as expected<br/> $tags = Doctrine::getTable('TaggableTag')-&gt;getPopularTags('BlogPost');</p> <p>$rel = Doctrine::getTable('BlogPost')-&gt;getRelations(); // is int(2)<br/> $rel = Doctrine::getTable('TagableTag')-&gt;getRelations(); // is int(2)</p> <p>Symfony 1.3 SVN updated as of this post.</p> <p>Ubuntu Karmic with PHP 5.3.1</p> <p>I have installed Taggable in mysymfonyproject/lib/doctrine_extensions/Taggable</p> <p>I have two example tables defined with Taggable:</p> <p>Video:<br/> actAs: </p> { Taggable: ~, Timestampable: ~ } <p> columns:<br/> id: </p> { type: integer, primary: true, autoincrement: true } <p> content_id: </p> { type: integer, notnull: true } <p> title: </p> { type: string(255) } <p> description: </p> { type: clob } <p> relations:<br/> Content: </p> { local: content_id, foreign: id } <p>Photo:<br/> actAs: </p> { Taggable: ~, Timestampable: ~ } <p> columns:<br/> id: </p> { type: integer, primary: true, autoincrement: true } <p> content_id: </p> { type: integer, notnull: true } <p> title: </p> { type: string(255) } <p> description: </p> { type: clob } <p> uri: </p> { type: string(255) } <p> relations:<br/> Content: </p> { local: content_id, foreign: id } <p>The following code functions and populates the database:<br/> $video = new Video();<br/> ...<br/> $video-&gt;setTags(implode(", ", $tags));<br/> $video-&gt;save();</p> <p>The following code errors:<br/> $tags = Doctrine::getTable('Video')-&gt;getPopularTags();</p> <p>500 | Internal Server Error | Doctrine_Table_Exception<br/> Unknown method VideoTable::getPopularTags</p> <p>The following code errors:<br/> $tags = Doctrine::getTable('TaggableTag')-&gt;getPopularTags('Video');</p> <p>500 | Internal Server Error | Doctrine_Exception<br/> Couldn't find class TagableTag</p> <p>Dont know if its related to this issue or not, but for some reason Doctrine::getTable('TaggableTag') throws a "</p> {Doctrine_Exception} <p> Couldn't find class TaggableTag" exception</p> <p>I understand that you would normally do this:<br/> Doctrine::getTable('Video')-&gt;getTags() <br/> but I just want plain access to the TaggableTag model and Doctrine doesnt seem to generate any model classess for TaggableTag </p> <p>I have tested everything everyone has provided and it is all working for me. The only thing I can suggest now is that someone creates a Doctrine failing test case so that I can run it to see the failure.</p> <p>Will create a test case this weekend for this and a few other problems I've across (with fixes). Nothing more frustrating than not being able to reproduce a problem, so I feel your pain.</p> <p>I think this bug i related to the bug in the documentation <a href="http://www.doctrine-project.org/jira/browse/DC-378" class="external-link">http://www.doctrine-project.org/jira/browse/DC-378</a> to get the popular tags you will first have to load the models you want the tags for.</p> <div class="code panel" style="border-width: 1px;"><div class="codeContent panelContent"> <pre class="code-java"><span class="code-comment">// load models that you want the tags from </span>Doctrine::getTable('blog'); Doctrine::getTable('products'); <span class="code-comment">// then you can get the tags <span class="code-keyword">for</span> the models currently loaded </span>$tags = Doctrine::getTable('TaggableTag')-&gt;getPopularTags(); </pre> </div></div> <p>This works for me:</p> <p>// load models that you want the tags from<br/> Doctrine::getTable('blog');<br/> Doctrine::getTable('products');<br/> // then you can get the tags for the models currently loaded<br/> $tags = Doctrine::getTable('TaggableTag')-&gt;getPopularTags();</p> <p>Okie... Creating test cases for this turned out to be more complicated than I can handle - myself not being that familiar with phpunit.<br/> Although within the test it is written as:<br/> $test = Doctrine::getTable('TaggableTag')-&gt;getPopularTags(array('ArticleTaggableTest', 'ArticleTaggableTest2'));<br/> Rather than:<br/> $test = Doctrine::getTable('ArticleTaggableTest')-&gt;getPopularTags();<br/> which is what this problem is about.</p> <p>Although I do believe I've nailed the source of the problem - as well as others I've experienced.</p> <ul class="alternate" type="square"> <li>Problems are introduced when using pear style model names. Indirectly fixed with: <a href="http://pastebin.com/DKGcgAht" class="external-link">http://pastebin.com/DKGcgAht</a> - links to fix in Doctrine/Record/Generator.php</li> <li>Problems are introduced when using custom names for the taggable field. Such as: <a href="http://pastebin.com/JdhqeG38" class="external-link">http://pastebin.com/JdhqeG38</a> - example</li> <li>Problems are introduced when using inheritance for models. Such as: <a href="http://pastebin.com/Qwuwk0z1" class="external-link">http://pastebin.com/Qwuwk0z1</a> - example</li> <li>Problems are introduced when using taggable relations when the record has not been inserted yet. Such as: <a href="http://pastebin.com/ahPpqTdK" class="external-link">http://pastebin.com/ahPpqTdK</a> - example</li> </ul> <p>Having either of the above causes the system to fall down. I've applied a bunch of fixes/changes to taggable to ensure it works with my systems, such as <a href="http://sos.7dots.co.uk/" class="external-link">http://sos.7dots.co.uk/</a> (still in staging) which uses all of the above mentioned problems, not sure how to do a diff but here is the file:<br/> <a href="http://www.2shared.com/file/12385197/c5911e42/Taggable.html" class="external-link">http://www.2shared.com/file/12385197/c5911e42/Taggable.html</a></p> <p>Hope that helps some people. Any changes I've made code can come under the same licence as doctrine, so no worries there.</p> <p>With 1.2.2 there is some progress.<br/> There was still 1 test failing (CASCADE),<br/> but with the version:<br/> <a href="http://www.2shared.com/file/12385197/c5911e42/Taggable.html" class="external-link">http://www.2shared.com/file/12385197/c5911e42/Taggable.html</a><br/> provided by Benjamin Arthur Lupton <br/> all test are passing now.</p> <p>But now when I run:<br/> getTable('ArticleTaggableTest')-&gt;getPopularTags();<br/> I get: ERROR: column "i2__1" does not exist</p> <p>The failing query on PostgreSql is:</p> <p>SELECT t.id AS t_<em>id, t.name AS t</em><em>name, COUNT(DISTINCT i.id) AS i</em>_0,<br/> (COUNT(DISTINCT i.id)) AS i__1<br/> FROM taggable_tag t<br/> LEFT JOIN cms_<em>model</em>_image_taggable_tag c ON (t.id = c.tag_id)<br/> LEFT JOIN image i ON i.id = c.id<br/> WHERE t.id IN<br/> (SELECT doctrine_subquery_alias.id<br/> FROM<br/> (SELECT DISTINCT t2.id, (COUNT(DISTINCT i2.id)) AS i2__1<br/> FROM taggable_tag t2<br/> LEFT JOIN cms_<em>model</em>_image_taggable_tag c2 ON (t2.id = c2.tag_id)<br/> LEFT JOIN image i2 ON i2.id = c2.id<br/> GROUP BY t2.id HAVING i2__1 &gt; 0<br/> ORDER BY i2__1 DESC LIMIT 10) AS doctrine_subquery_alias)<br/> GROUP BY t.id HAVING i__1 &gt; 0<br/> ORDER BY i__1 DESC</p> <p>Seems that this just a PostgreSql issue.<br/> On Mysql it runs just fine.</p> <p>The last comment is concerning how the poular tags are found and rated (on PostgreSql). I think this is unrelated to the rest of this issue and should be moved to a separate issue. (also I only got junk ads when I tried to get the file you are linking to).</p> <p>I have created separated issue for this:<br/> <a href="http://www.doctrine-project.org/jira/browse/DC-634" class="external-link">http://www.doctrine-project.org/jira/browse/DC-634</a></p> <p>And yes, this link is quite odd...<br/> There is a lot of crap,<br/> however there is a small link, to download improved code:</p> <p>Look for: "Save file to your PC: click here"</p>